Follow Scott
Recent Tweets
- Waiting for Twitter... Once Twitter is ready they will display my Tweets again.
Latest Photos
Search
Tags
anniversary Balticon birthdays Bryan Voltaggio Capclave comics Cons context-free comic book panel conventions DC Comics dreams Eating the Fantastic food garden Grant Achatz horror Irene Vartanoff Jack Kirby Man v. Food Marie Severin Marvel Comics My Father my writing Nebula Awards Next restaurant obituaries old magazines Paris Review Readercon rejection slips San Diego Comic-Con Scarecrow science fiction Science Fiction Age Sharon Moody Stan Lee Stoker Awards StokerCon Superman ukulele Video Worldcon World Fantasy Convention World Horror Convention zombies
Barry Pearl
Dear Scott:
I read your thoughtful blog on Kirby and Captain America and, if you don’t mind me adding something, I like to point out a few things.
First, I agree that Kirby’s writing technique was not compelling, nor was it very good. He did work better with a collaborator be it Lee or Simon.
But I am giving him a pass over the comment that you object so strongly about, in issue #207 for a number of reasons:
First, I was around then too, and this was the era of the Viet Nam war and we had grown tired of America being the policeman of the world. When he says, “This is not my country and not my place to fight for causes I know nothing about” he was expressing what many people were feeling at the time, perhaps even what he, himself was thinking, that things can be bad in other countries but we cannot, or should not interfere everywhere even when we saw horrible things.
But it is his bad dialoguing that gets in the way of his actual plotting. Perhaps he could have cleared it up by continuing saying something like, “unless I have a good reason.” Soon, when given that good reason, Cap goes into action and fights the bad guys. This was common in storytelling especially in comics. That is, give a reason why you don’t get involved and then the writer finds a reason why you should. Did we ever really think he won’t get involved?
I think Kirby was trying to show the moral conflict we were all facing at the time. Now, when I read it out of context it has a different meaning. But during the latter part of the Viet Nam conflict we were battling ourselves and each other over these issues.
Funny, with Iraqi we faced some of the same issues. I guess we will never resolve this conflict.